The Merriest and Most Official Secret Santa Rules When You’re Hosting a Jolly Gift Exchange!

Put on your best poker face because it's about to be an epic Secret Santa party!

If you buy something from the links on this page, we may earn a commission. How We Do It!

Official Secret Santa Rules 2024

I’ve hosted more White Elephant parties than I have Secret Santa parties and while there are many ways to set up a Secret Santa gift exchange, I’ve narrowed down the entire process to six quick and easy to follow steps.

So, as the winter wonderland awaits, and Santa’s sleigh gears up for its annual voyage, we gather around with twinkling eyes (maybe because we’re buzzed) and hearts full of joy (and eggnog) to partake in this merry mystery. But hark! Santa has bestowed upon us a scroll of Secret Santa rules, wrapped in a bow of laughter and cheer, to ensure this Secret Santa gift-giving extravaganza is nothing short of spectacular!

So buckle up your reindeer sleighs, and let’s take a joyous ride through the whimsical world of Secret Santa, where surprises await, laughter echoes, and the spirit of giving brightens every corner. Ready? Let’s spread some holiday cheer with these official Secret Santa rules that guarantee a sleigh-full of smiles!  Oh, and we’re officially over the puns – for now.


Rule #1: The Drawing of the Names

The first step in this merry dance is drawing names. Gather all participants, scribble names on colorful slips of paper, and place them in a Santa hat (or any festive container of your choice!).

There are a few different ways you can choose names and see who gets who:

  • Traditional Drawing: Write each participant’s name on separate slips of paper and place them in a container. Have each person draw a name without looking and keep it secret.

  • Online Name Generator: If it’s not feasible to gather in person, use an online Secret Santa name generator. Many websites and apps offer this service, ensuring a randomized and fair name assignment.

  • Digital Drawing: For in-person gatherings, use a digital tool that randomly assigns names, such as a random name picker app or website projected on a screen.

  • No Self-Picking: Emphasize that participants cannot pick themselves. If someone draws their name, they must return the slip and redraw.

  • Couples or Family Members: Decide whether couples or family members participating in the Secret Santa should be drawn together or kept separate. Some groups prefer drawing individuals, while others allow couples or family members to be treated as one entity.

Remember, this part is crucial – keep those names a secret! 


Rule #2: Setting the Budget

To keep things jolly and fair, agree on a budget that fits everyone’s stockings. Be it a modest elf-worthy budget or a more lavish Santa’s splurge, the key is to ensure everyone feels comfortable and included.


Rule #3: Creating the Wishlist

Ah, the wishlist! It’s like sending a letter to the North Pole, but in reverse. Encourage everyone to create a wishlist that’s both thoughtful and whimsical. Include hints, favorite colors, hobbies, and maybe even a little joke or two to keep the guessing game entertaining.


Rule #4: Keeping It Secret (Shh!)

No peeking, no prodding, and no prying! The identity of each Secret Santa must remain hidden until the big reveal. Embrace the suspense and let the mystery unfold until the grand gift-giving moment arrives.


Rule #5: The Stealthy Delivery

Sneakiness is the name of the game! Disguise your handwriting, enlist Santa’s little helpers to drop off the presents, or go incognito with a mysterious gift box. The element of surprise adds an extra sprinkle of joy.


Rule #6: Guessing Game

Ah, the highlight of the Secret Santa reveal – the guessing game! Gather in a circle, take turns guessing who played Santa for whom. This is usually when everyone is laughing over all the guesses.  Hey, sometimes a little holiday egg nog makes things funnier too.

Fun, But Important Things to Keep in Mind

Look, at the end of the day this Secret Santa exchange is support to be fun.  But there are still some things we think are important to keep in mind:

  • Gratitude and Grace – No matter the gift, it’s essential to embrace the spirit of gratitude. Thank your Secret Santa with heartfelt appreciation, regardless of whether it’s a perfect fit or not. It’s the thought that counts, and the joy of giving is what matters most.

  • Inclusivity Matters – Remember, not everyone may celebrate the same holidays during this festive season. Be mindful of the diverse backgrounds of participants, and consider using more generic terms like “Holiday Gift Exchange” or “Winter Wonderland Surprise” to ensure everyone feels welcome.

  • Virtual Celebrations – If distance keeps your group apart, fret not! Embrace technology with virtual Secret Santa parties. Use video calls for the big reveal and witness the joy of surprise across the digital divide.

Fun Secret Santa Themes

Part of the fun of having a Secret Santa exchange is to come up with a theme that’ll work for everyone and provide a little direction on the type of gift they should focus in on. 

Here are some gift theme ideas we’ve come up with you may want to consider:

  • Ugly Sweater Surprise: Participants exchange quirky and festive-themed ugly sweaters, adding a touch of humor and holiday spirit to the gift swap.

  • Bookworm’s Delight: Embrace the love of reading by exchanging favorite books, literary classics, or even personalized book recommendations.

  • Sweet Treat Extravaganza: Each Secret Santa gift centers around delectable treats like gourmet chocolates, homemade cookies, or a selection of candies.

  • Pamper Yourself: Indulge in self-care by gifting items like scented candles, bath bombs, face masks, and other luxurious pampering products.

  • Travel Treasures: Exchange travel-inspired gifts, such as travel guides, travel-themed decor, or even a scratch-off map to mark their adventures.

  • Geeky Gadgets Galore: For the tech-savvy, give gifts ranging from cool gadgets and accessories to quirky tech-themed items.

  • DIY Delights: Embrace creativity by exchanging handmade gifts like knitted scarves, handcrafted ornaments, or personalized artworks.

  • Green Thumb Wonderland: Perfect for plant lovers, gifts can include potted plants, terrariums, or gardening tools to cultivate their green oasis.

  • Movie Magic: Give the gift of entertainment with DVDs, movie posters, popcorn, or movie night essentials.

  • Around the World Fiesta: Explore global cultures with gifts representing different countries or regions, such as international snacks, souvenirs, or cultural artifacts.


So there you have it, the Secret Santa rules that will make your gift swap sparkle with joy and delight. Embrace the magic, embrace the mystery, and let the spirit of giving guide you on this festive adventure. Happy gifting, Secret Santas!